Two scary supply side stories

The labour market and productivity are both supply side constructs and have an impact on the long term growth path of the economy.

Here are two stories from the New York Times: One is a personal story and the other a data story.

Basically as labour markets get tight (or as unemployment declines) wages tend to increase.  Unfortunately they are not.  Not just in the US but also in some other European countries.

The articles put it down to skills and the decline of unions.  Skills are shifting from the middle to the low and high end.  This is a structural problem. Its no wonder Singapore always emphasizes skills upgrading. At the end of the day we should expect inequality to increase. Partly also due to the gig economy.

The other is a scary story from the UK - productivity growth has declined - which means long term growth will decline.  Here is the full report from the The Office for Budget responsibility. But if you don't want to read that, watch this video they posted on twitter.

Coase and Pigou

Here are two articles on Pigouvian Taxes and The Coase Theorem - I have shown you a picture of the former and will discuss the latter next week. The first article provides various examples of the use of these taxes to deal with externalities. The Coase theorem has applications beyond externalities.

It is the foundation of the transactions cost literature and the literature on contracts. This literature also provides us another way to look at markets and suggests that firms are substitutes for markets. They are both 'governance mechanisms' - they govern the conduct of transactions and the costs of using these two governance mechanisms determines which one is more likely to be used.

It also helps us to understand contracts and vertical integration. For example, we should expect to observe long term contracts or vertical integration in the aluminum value chain. This is because an alumina refinery can only accept a particular grade of bauxite and and aluminum smelter can only accept a particular grade of alumina. This type of exchange cannot be carried out using markets.



Europe - Deficient Demand

Here is an article from the NYT by Paul Krugman on Europe.  And a slide deck he refers to.  The slide deck shows us a number of things:

  • Output and capacity utilization are well below potential
  • The crisis reduced Europe's potential GDP
  • Investment has tanked
  • US productivity is way higher than Europe's
  • Interest rates are low
  • People do not expect inflation (or expect low inflation)
  • Bank lending to the private sector has tanked

Krugman is arguing for a Keynesian fiscal response to tackle the demand deficiency.